|
Post by holajonathan on Aug 28, 2021 3:09:53 GMT -5
I am thinking about using this 8" grinder with 80 grit and 220 grit sintered wheels for cabs and putting 6 resin wheels on my Genie. Is anyone else running resin wheels only on their cab machine? If so, what grits are you using?
A related question -- I recently bought 6" and 8" 120 grit Top brand resin wheels to see what they are all about. I knew they would be less aggressive than hard wheels, but despite being 120 grit, they work much more like a 280 resin wheel than a 220 hard wheel. They do leave scratches, but much less, it seems than a 220 hard. Has anyone tried going from a 220 hard to a coarser grade resin wheel? The 280 soft wheel is where I spend way too much time, and I am hoping that adding a step between the 220 hard and the 280 soft might speed up the process. I tried to get a Nova 220, but Diamond Pacific no longer makes them. Not even for special orders.
|
|
|
Post by stardiamond on Aug 28, 2021 4:39:26 GMT -5
Was Galaxy 220 a typo? Did you mean a 220 Nova soft wheel? Johnson brothers offers theirs for $64.95: www.johnsonbrotherslapidary.com/NW-6-220.htmlI have an 8 inch 220 and a 6 inch 325 mounted on my machines. I bought an 8 inch 220 grit top resin wheel but haven't mounted it. It didn't have as much cushioning as a DP or JB wheel. I was over using my 280 soft but now I do most of my work on the top 80 hard and a worn DP 80 hard. Shape with the 80 grits and use the 220 hard and 280 soft just to remove scratches.
|
|
|
Post by holajonathan on Aug 28, 2021 13:50:58 GMT -5
Was Galaxy 220 a typo? Did you mean a 220 Nova soft wheel? Johnson brothers offers theirs for $64.95: www.johnsonbrotherslapidary.com/NW-6-220.htmlI have an 8 inch 220 and a 6 inch 325 mounted on my machines. I bought an 8 inch 220 grit top resin wheel but haven't mounted it. It didn't have as much cushioning as a DP or JB wheel. I was over using my 280 soft but now I do most of my work on the top 80 hard and a worn DP 80 hard. Shape with the 80 grits and use the 220 hard and 280 soft just to remove scratches. Yes, typo, I meant 220 Nova. DP no longer makes them per Ron on Ebay. He can't get them, special order or otherwise. I will try one of those from Johnson Brothers. I haven't gotten the greatest customer service from them, but I don't see anyone else offering a 220 soft wheel. I think maybe I need to spend more time on the 220 hard. In theory, 220 grit scratches should come out fairly easily on the first soft wheel. So when they don't, I suppose I am still fighting scratches from the 80 grit. I have a hard time telling if I've done enough with the 220 hard until I've already wasted a lot of time on the 280 soft.
|
|
nik
spending too much on rocks
Member since May 2019
Posts: 315
|
Post by nik on Aug 28, 2021 16:55:35 GMT -5
Have you considered using an expanding drum with belts? My standard progression is some combination of 30, 80, 120, and 220 sintered, then to a 220 8x3 belt, and go to rez style wheels from 600 to prepolish. I also have a 140 belt that I have only used a few times, but it is nice for rough shaping softer and fragile material, also handy as a first soft stage for really big stones.
|
|
|
Post by holajonathan on Sept 1, 2021 14:45:39 GMT -5
Was Galaxy 220 a typo? Did you mean a 220 Nova soft wheel? Johnson brothers offers theirs for $64.95: www.johnsonbrotherslapidary.com/NW-6-220.htmlI have an 8 inch 220 and a 6 inch 325 mounted on my machines. I bought an 8 inch 220 grit top resin wheel but haven't mounted it. It didn't have as much cushioning as a DP or JB wheel. I was over using my 280 soft but now I do most of my work on the top 80 hard and a worn DP 80 hard. Shape with the 80 grits and use the 220 hard and 280 soft just to remove scratches. I have read some of your posts where you discuss your equipment and your desire to speed up the cabbing process, even if that means spending more on wheels and equipment. I agree. My first (unsuccessful) idea was to buy a 30 grit 8" sintered wheel. I don't need to explain why this was a bad idea. (Anyone want to buy a lightly used 8" 30 grit sintered wheel?) For me, the slowest steps in cabbing are: 1) grinding the preform and the dome with an 80 grit hard wheel, and 2) removing scratches from the 80 wheel; and 3) rounding off the ridges created by hard wheels. In other words, the first 3 wheels is where I spend 90% of my time. But if I do those steps right, I can finish the cab, including final polish on rawhide, in 10 minutes or less. Here is my plan to speed up the slow steps: Covington 8" Grinder:
8" sintered 80 grit and 220 grit wheels to finish shaping preform and to grind the dome. Using this grinder, I can do those steps two or three times faster than on the Genie. I can press fairly hard on the 220 sintered wheel and actually remove some material without creating deep scratches. The Genie:The 2nd to 6th wheels will be resin grits 220, 280, 600, 1200, and 3000. I have a spin-on 14,000 when needed, but with agates and jaspers I can usually go right from the 3000 to final polish on rawhide + Linde A AO polish. Adding in a 220 grit resin should speed up the transition from the hard wheels to the resin wheels. That leaves the first wheel on the Genie. Two options: a 325 sintered hard or a 140 resin. I already own the 140 soft, but I will buy a 325 sintered if it is a better option. I think the 325 hard would do better to finish removing scratches from the 80 grit that I didn't get all the way out with the 220. In other words, if get to the soft wheels and realize there is a scratch that I overlooked, I wouldn't have to change machines and go back to the grinder to get it out. Trying to get any real scratch out with a resin wheel is an utter waste of time. The advantage of the 140 soft, I think, is that it will quickly smooth the dome and allow me to fly through all of the other resin wheels. In my experience, the 140 grit resin is lousy at removing scratches but it sands and smooth very quickly. It's not much better at removing scratches than a 280 resin, but it does sand a lot faster than a 280. Any thoughts on this? Thanks for your help.
|
|
|
Post by stardiamond on Sept 1, 2021 17:32:13 GMT -5
Once I started using the top 80 6 inch wheels I have no desire to use the 8 inch 80. As soon as a top 80 wheel losses it's aggressiveness, I replace it. It is mounted on an extra Genie right side arbor. On the left side I have the standard DP set up. The 80 cuts but it is tame. It removes the top 80 scratches and fine tunes the shape. I spend 75% of my time on the two 80 grit which where all the shaping is done. The rest is 220 hard 280 soft and then to the right arbor with 220 soft and 325, This is for flat spots and scratches. I use the 600 and 1200 8inch wheels for sanding and then back to the Genie with a right hand arbor for 3000, 14,000, 50,000 and then 100,000 diamond paste. I could skip the 220, 325, 14,000 and 50,000 soft wheels. They are another chance to see problems and they are only tickled.
|
|
|
Post by holajonathan on Sept 2, 2021 12:27:58 GMT -5
Once I started using the top 80 6 inch wheels I have no desire to use the 8 inch 80. As soon as a top 80 wheel losses it's aggressiveness, I replace it. It is mounted on an extra Genie right side arbor. On the left side I have the standard DP set up. The 80 cuts but it is tame. It removes the top 80 scratches and fine tunes the shape. I spend 75% of my time on the two 80 grit which where all the shaping is done. The rest is 220 hard 280 soft and then to the right arbor with 220 soft and 325, This is for flat spots and scratches. I use the 600 and 1200 8inch wheels for sanding and then back to the Genie with a right hand arbor for 3000, 14,000, 50,000 and then 100,000 diamond paste. I could skip the 220, 325, 14,000 and 50,000 soft wheels. They are another chance to see problems and they are only tickled. Thanks for the info. Maybe I need to try the Top 80 grit. When you say you replace it when it gets slow, approximately how often does that happen? Ever 100 cabs? 500 cabs? 6 months? One year? Are you using the regular plated 80, or the textured? They have a 100 grit textured for sale on Ebay for around $80. If textured really is more aggressive, that might make a good replacement for the Galaxy 80, which has never cut very fast except when breaking it in. Any particular reason why 600 and 1200 are the grits you moved to your 8" machine? Here's why I ask: I really do find 8" wheels to work faster than 6" ones, at least with my machines (Covington Grinder & Genie). As a result, my instinct is that the wheels I spend the most time using should be 8" wheels. For me, that would be 80 grit and 220 grit hard. A 220 soft on my 8" machine would also be very nice since an 8" x 2" wide wheel would allow me to quickly round off the dome after the hard wheels and remove scratches from the 220 hard. I value your opinions on this subject since I have seen the number of good looking cabs you can produce in a day, and we both have a 6" Genie and 8" two-wheel machine in the mix.
|
|
|
Post by holajonathan on Sept 2, 2021 12:31:10 GMT -5
Have you considered using an expanding drum with belts? My standard progression is some combination of 30, 80, 120, and 220 sintered, then to a 220 8x3 belt, and go to rez style wheels from 600 to prepolish. I also have a 140 belt that I have only used a few times, but it is nice for rough shaping softer and fragile material, also handy as a first soft stage for really big stones. I have not, but I am open to experimenting with one at some point. The 3" width is very appealing, although I would have to figure out how to get water to the whole wheel. Other than the width, what do you believe is the advantage of the drum + belt vs. a 220 soft wheel? Thank you for your input.
|
|
|
Post by stardiamond on Sept 2, 2021 13:03:22 GMT -5
Once I started using the top 80 6 inch wheels I have no desire to use the 8 inch 80. As soon as a top 80 wheel losses it's aggressiveness, I replace it. It is mounted on an extra Genie right side arbor. On the left side I have the standard DP set up. The 80 cuts but it is tame. It removes the top 80 scratches and fine tunes the shape. I spend 75% of my time on the two 80 grit which where all the shaping is done. The rest is 220 hard 280 soft and then to the right arbor with 220 soft and 325, This is for flat spots and scratches. I use the 600 and 1200 8inch wheels for sanding and then back to the Genie with a right hand arbor for 3000, 14,000, 50,000 and then 100,000 diamond paste. I could skip the 220, 325, 14,000 and 50,000 soft wheels. They are another chance to see problems and they are only tickled. Thanks for the info. Maybe I need to try the Top 80 grit. When you say you replace it when it gets slow, approximately how often does that happen? Ever 100 cabs? 500 cabs? 6 months? One year? Are you using the regular plated 80, or the textured? They have a 100 grit textured for sale on Ebay for around $80. If textured really is more aggressive, that might make a good replacement for the Galaxy 80, which has never cut very fast except when breaking it in. Any particular reason why 600 and 1200 are the grits you moved to your 8" machine? Here's why I ask: I really do find 8" wheels to work faster than 6" ones, at least with my machines (Covington Grinder & Genie). As a result, my instinct is that the wheels I spend the most time using should be 8" wheels. For me, that would be 80 grit and 220 grit hard. A 220 soft on my 8" machine would also be very nice since an 8" x 2" wide wheel would allow me to quickly round off the dome after the hard wheels and remove scratches from the 220 hard. I value your opinions on this subject since I have seen the number of good looking cabs you can produce in a day, and we both have a 6" Genie and 8" two-wheel machine in the mix. My current top is a textured plastic core 80 grit top. Previous top was a steel core 80 grit top. When I bought the textured, I also bought a steel core textured that I haven't mounted. They gave me a reduced price on one of them. The current textured wheel has been on the arbor for 10 weeks and is still aggressive. I got my first machine, a 8 inch stardiamond with worn 80 and 220 galaxy. The cabs were finished with a 400 grit lapidary belt sander and tin oxide on leather. I was not happy with some of the results. I bought a Genie. After a while, I thought I could add more wheels to the stardiamond. I removed the everything and bought some spacers. Replaced with 80,220 hard, 220/280 soft, 600, 1200 soft. I used the Genie for prepolishing and diamond paste polishing. Replacing the wheels on the stardiamond is a paint, removing all the bolts and the canvas pad. Removing everything from the arbor in sequence, wheels and spacers and then replacing each wheel with a new one and putting everything back on the arbor and back into the machine. Takes over an hour. I bought new 80 and 220 hard from jadecarver and a 220 soft from JB. The 600 and 1200 were hardly used and I noticed they needed some break in. I developed some arthritis in my thumbs and the cabbing position on the Genie is better. I decided to buy another right hand arbor and the top wheel. Cutting speed with the top was as good as the 8 inch jadecarver, so I didn't bother to replace the other wheels. Speed is the only issue with 80 grit. I like the wider wheels for the 600 and 1200 and they are already mounted.
|
|
|
Post by holajonathan on Sept 2, 2021 14:25:04 GMT -5
Thanks for the info. Maybe I need to try the Top 80 grit. When you say you replace it when it gets slow, approximately how often does that happen? Ever 100 cabs? 500 cabs? 6 months? One year? Are you using the regular plated 80, or the textured? They have a 100 grit textured for sale on Ebay for around $80. If textured really is more aggressive, that might make a good replacement for the Galaxy 80, which has never cut very fast except when breaking it in. Any particular reason why 600 and 1200 are the grits you moved to your 8" machine? Here's why I ask: I really do find 8" wheels to work faster than 6" ones, at least with my machines (Covington Grinder & Genie). As a result, my instinct is that the wheels I spend the most time using should be 8" wheels. For me, that would be 80 grit and 220 grit hard. A 220 soft on my 8" machine would also be very nice since an 8" x 2" wide wheel would allow me to quickly round off the dome after the hard wheels and remove scratches from the 220 hard. I value your opinions on this subject since I have seen the number of good looking cabs you can produce in a day, and we both have a 6" Genie and 8" two-wheel machine in the mix. My current top is a textured plastic core 80 grit top. Previous top was a steel core 80 grit top. When I bought the textured, I also bought a steel core textured that I haven't mounted. They gave me a reduced price on one of them. The current textured wheel has been on the arbor for 10 weeks and is still aggressive. I got my first machine, a 8 inch stardiamond with worn 80 and 220 galaxy. The cabs were finished with a 400 grit lapidary belt sander and tin oxide on leather. I was not happy with some of the results. I bought a Genie. After a while, I thought I could add more wheels to the stardiamond. I removed the everything and bought some spacers. Replaced with 80,220 hard, 220/280 soft, 600, 1200 soft. I used the Genie for prepolishing and diamond paste polishing. Replacing the wheels on the stardiamond is a paint, removing all the bolts and the canvas pad. Removing everything from the arbor in sequence, wheels and spacers and then replacing each wheel with a new one and putting everything back on the arbor and back into the machine. Takes over an hour. I bought new 80 and 220 hard from jadecarver and a 220 soft from JB. The 600 and 1200 were hardly used and I noticed they needed some break in. I developed some arthritis in my thumbs and the cabbing position on the Genie is better. I decided to buy another right hand arbor and the top wheel. Cutting speed with the top was as good as the 8 inch jadecarver, so I didn't bother to replace the other wheels. Speed is the only issue with 80 grit. I like the wider wheels for the 600 and 1200 and they are already mounted. Thanks for the additional information, including the evolution of how you got to your current setup. One last question: Having used both the normal plated Top 80 grit and the textured, do you prefer the textured? I understand the tradeoffs in general. I am interested in your specific take on the Top brand normal plated vs textured. The small difference in price is not an issue if you think the tradeoffs are good in terms of speed vs. longevity, speed vs. precision and control, etc...
|
|
|
Post by stardiamond on Sept 2, 2021 15:24:29 GMT -5
I think I prefer the textured. More aggressive and seems to maintain it. On the negative, more aggressive but still not chippy. I picked up a 60 grit crystalring cheap some years ago and it was too chippy for me to use. I would be more cautious buying a top quality sintered wheel, but these are inexpensive so no worries.
|
|
|
Post by holajonathan on Sept 3, 2021 10:27:26 GMT -5
I think I prefer the textured. More aggressive and seems to maintain it. On the negative, more aggressive but still not chippy. I picked up a 60 grit crystalring cheap some years ago and it was too chippy for me to use. I would be more cautious buying a top quality sintered wheel, but these are inexpensive so no worries. Thanks again for all the info. I appreciate it.
|
|