Roan
has rocks in the head
Member since January 2008
Posts: 600
|
Post by Roan on Mar 3, 2008 15:24:54 GMT -5
. . .Chakra tuning. The alledged ailment is that a mis-tuned chakra isn't "spinning" at it's proper speed (frequency), and the alledged "cure" is to "tune" the chakra. I don't think any educated, reasonably intelligent person could help but see the many variables which would need to be addressed in order for this to have any hope of doing what is claimed to be done. . . . I'm really pleased the discussion has changed to an actual discussion of how it could or could not work instead of just bashing et al. Now, chakra -- explain more in depth? I have a vague idea, but I need the logistics behind it. Vibrations. About 5 months ago I had no idea about any of this stuff. Never even knew people used crystals for healing et al. Didn't have a tumbler and didn't have anything to do with rocks at all. Rocks were just rocks, y'know? Some were just prettier than others. My dressage trainer is into it big time and so are many of the borders at the barn. Anyhow, my trainer was showing one of the borders a "cool rock" she found in the pasture. I just kinda looked at it and didn't hold it or anything. They didn't say what it was that supposedly made the rock so different and I didn't ask. It was just a small rock; a nondescript rusty beige color that was rather ugly. I didn't see what all the excitement was about. I started to ask my trainer a question about my horse, and Jen (the border) took the rock and put it on the back of my hand. I musta jumped 5 feet when she did that. All I could say was, "WHAT THE *($% " Jen asked me if the rock had felt warm, and I said "NO! The damn thing was vibrating!" Totally freaked me out! Ever since that happened I've been asking questions here and there. Since then I've felt other rocks vibrate as well and I want to know WHY? Why can I feel some rocks vibrate? Eileen
|
|
oriongal
noticing nice landscape pebbles
Member since May 2007
Posts: 96
|
Post by oriongal on Mar 3, 2008 16:41:48 GMT -5
Oddly enough, the one thing that made me a bit less of a skeptic when it comes to some things that might be considered 'metaphysical' was not anything at all metaphysical itself - it was purely scientific. It was the theory behind electricity, electronics and magnetism that really got me wondering about some things.
Take a basic accepted tenet of electricity - it is neither created nor destroyed. It may change state (from static, at rest, to kinetic, in motion), but it never ceases to exist.
Then take the basic medical definition of life - it is not a heartbeat, or respiration - you can be 'dead' while still having both. It is primarily coherent brain wave activity that pretty well defines life in the medical realm.
So, if brain waves = life, and brain waves are electrical in nature, and electricity can't be destroyed...does this then hint at the possible provable existence of the soul? Maybe - maybe not - but since apparitions don't have anything solid to hook an EEG to, we're probably not going to be able to measure whether there is still coherent and cohesive electrical impulses involved with the phenomena that are called ghosts anytime soon. If someone ever makes an EEG-like device that can read a living human's brain wave activity from several feet away (discarding all the other electronic 'noise' that our world generates in the process, quite a tall order), then something like that might be able to prove or disprove ghosts as well. Until then, some will believe and some will not, and there's nothing concrete to say either side is right or wrong.
Michaeljohn, your explanation of chakra tuning (which I knew nothing about myself) actually doesn't sound quite as far-fetched as you might think. Ever studied any radio theory, in specific crystal tuners used in radio transmitters/receivers? The same crystal can produce quite a spectrum of different frequencies, by nothing more than tiny changes in the level of physical stress put on them, or electrical energy used to stimulate them. We (human beings) certainly produce electricity (and where there is kinetic electrical energy, there is also magnetism), and one can certainly hold a crystal more or less tightly - possibly until it just feels 'right'. Is that proof of anything, of course not - but at the same time it doesn't seem to conflict significantly with what is known about crystals as used in electronic applications either.
I still say that there is a whole lot that we just don't know. Are there fakers and shams in the crystal world, oh, I'm 100% sure there are. No doubt in my mind on that at all. There are fakers and shams in the medical world, the financial world, and even the scientific world as well. But their existence doesn't make a sham of the entire realm they're inhabiting. It's just that we have the ability to separate the wheat from the chaff in the realms that we know the most about, where there is no such ability to separate the same in realms we don't know anything (provable) about.
|
|
snivlem
starting to spend too much on rocks
Member since February 2008
Posts: 167
|
Post by snivlem on Mar 3, 2008 16:56:06 GMT -5
All matter is energy vibrating.
So what!
Doesn't it make you smile!
And oriongal- you are right on. Anyone who "believes" is a fool, anyone who denies possibility without "proof" is a fool. Ah, to be at home in a world full of fools!
Nothing is everything!
|
|
rollingstone
starting to spend too much on rocks
Member since July 2009
Posts: 236
|
Post by rollingstone on Mar 4, 2008 4:04:45 GMT -5
Hocus, Pocus.... I've cured you with this rock. That'll be $100. NEXT!!!!!!!!!
|
|
|
Post by bobby1 on Mar 6, 2008 20:03:07 GMT -5
I saw a quote by Redd Foxx and it went something like "You can eat all the best foods, get a lot of exercise, be extra cautious and you will be lying in the hospital at 80 years old dying of nothin' " Or to quote Dean Edell you can do all of the above and add an extra 10 years to your life in the assisted living facility hooked up to tubes and having someone wipe your backside as they change your diaper and roll you on your side to prevent bedsores. Maybe the "healy - feely stuff will resolve all of this? Bob
|
|
|
Post by cpdad on Mar 6, 2008 23:29:31 GMT -5
that will be 100$...hahahahaha ;D. when cp and me was talking bout science projects a while back....he brought up this dude...marcel vogel...but it was a little to complicated to understand at first...and for the time frame needed. do i beleive...nope...not as of now....but who knows...maybe they are on to something...kev. meta-religion.com/Paranormale/Other/crystal_skull.htm
|
|
Roan
has rocks in the head
Member since January 2008
Posts: 600
|
Post by Roan on Mar 7, 2008 0:15:55 GMT -5
I saw a quote by Redd Foxx and it went something like "You can eat all the best foods, get a lot of exercise, be extra cautious and you will be lying in the hospital at 80 years old dying of nothin' " Or to quote Dean Edell you can do all of the above and add an extra 10 years to your life in the assisted living facility hooked up to tubes and having someone wipe your backside as they change your diaper and roll you on your side to prevent bedsores. Maybe the "healy - feely stuff will resolve all of this? Bob Bob, there's a shorter way of saying it: "Good health is just a slower way of dying." One sentence Eileen
|
|
WarrenA
fully equipped rock polisher
Member since November 2003
Posts: 1,530
|
Post by WarrenA on Mar 7, 2008 0:58:45 GMT -5
I had a friend stop in my shop and ask for a piece of rough amethyst. He said another friend of his had been diagnosed with stomach cancer and had heard that amethyst would help. So I GAVE a piece away. If someone believes that it will help who am I to say no. If having a rock in your pocket gives you some piece of mind good for you. I don't have all the answers never will and I know there are things that work and defy explanation.
|
|
MidNight~Rocksi3
fully equipped rock polisher
Member since January 2008
Posts: 1,716
|
Post by MidNight~Rocksi3 on Mar 7, 2008 4:46:34 GMT -5
I didn't know they vibrated either ... I've had some odd experiences with Crystals too.. I was going to clean these one crystals we dug up, and as I was checking out this Clear Crystal it felt a little strange to me because I couldn't believe it started to get super cold.. and it even fogged up... Why some do that? I don't know..but it was cool... I remember thinking there must be more to them than just keeping time.. because if NASA is collecting them in a mad way.. and.. I doubt it's for their watches... Oh and I did recently find out that quartz will spark if you hit two together.... but if you take two other kinds of rocks and hit them together they wont spark...I'm sure there is some scientific reason behind it..... I just don't know what it is What about Copper? It's known for the ability to stop the pain of artharitis... I know it's been proven that the human body also can absorb things through the skin.... That's why some people have a hard time with wearing jewelry..... Maybe thats how the stones are able to affect the body.. I don't think it's magic or hocus pocus ... Just so simple it's easy to look over it.. But I can see where most will claim coincidence or prayer or something .. just like any kind belief that has no facts.... only experiences.. they are still trying to prove that bible is fact.... and those people think man can walk on water... and some doubt that a stone might be able to calm the spirit?... or hold a Natural healing property? I'm just glad you girls were able to bring this subject and brought out the stones to a somewhat scientific standpoint.. There is no harder thing to do, than to prove to skeptics who can only grasp an idea if it has a FDA stamp of approval or some solid study with Documented Proof and facts.... That something So simple that isn't Man Made, Can toss all the rule books and medical researches out the window.......would they ever try to find out themselves? .. lol I doubt it.. ;D That's where the having an open mind ... comes in... and for some reason... that's the hardest thing for some people to do... and maybe that's why those that do keep an open mind.. see the world and things totally different than those who don't.. *smiles* But I'm so glad I got my lucky rock in my pocket.. sure has been good to me these past few weeks... ;D Thanks T.
|
|
|
Post by Michael John on Mar 7, 2008 8:11:31 GMT -5
Although a lot of VERY nice and comforting things have been told by many here whom I know from their years of posting to be wonderful people, still nothing has been said which strengthens the case for rocks actually having the metaphysical powers claimed by "the new age crowd". Many have mentioned strange experiences with crystals, some of which ARE fact, but none of these phenomenon correlate with proven physical or psychological benefits.
Have you seen all of the hokey, outlandish claims made about the "miraculous powers" of rocks? It's absolutely ridiculous! Just go to any of the "new age" sites which sell rocks and see for yourself!
Here's a great example ... Chrysocolla. These are some of the claims made about it's metaphysical benefits:
* Encourages harmony, neutrality, clarity, and tranquility * Cleanses and purifies the home * Releases tension * Calms and balances emotions * Eliminates negativity and doubt * Assists in communications, internally and externally * Opens one's mind to creativity, free thinking, and free will * Promotes compassion * Allows forgiveness * Replaces guilt with understanding * Replaces depression with inner strength * Brings about polarity integration * Helps one to be more in-tune with the earth * Replenishes the will to act responsibly * Encourages the developement of intuition * Promotes the global developement of unconditional love
Guess where I copied that from, to paste here ... MY OWN eBay Guide about Chrysocolla! Where did I get that load of utter nonsense? It's a compilation directly taken from various "new age" rip-off sites on the internet. I included it in my Guide so that maybe some of the "new agers" would buy my Chrysocolla at a fair market price instead of getting ripped-off by "new age" predators. However, to my knowledge, nobody has bought my Chrysocolla for anything other than lapidary use. Probably because my Chrysocolla hasn't been "Reiki Charged"? LMAO
I wonder if these "new age" peddlers are descendents of the guys who used to drive their covered wagons from town to town, peddling Snake Oil...
|
|
grayfingers
Cave Dweller
Member since November 2007
Posts: 4,575
|
Post by grayfingers on Mar 7, 2008 9:09:19 GMT -5
I agree with Michaeljohn, I am sure that history shows us that there are always unsavory individuals that attempt to profit from people's fears, kinda like carbon credits and crossover cars for the global warming cultists. Having said that, I carry around a pocket agate, not to link to some mystical power, but because I like it. Anything that reduces one's stress has to be a good thing, people are free to believe what they will, and aside from rip-offs, I really think they are at the least contributing to overall interest in rocks.
|
|
fanatic
starting to spend too much on rocks
Member since October 2007
Posts: 233
|
Post by fanatic on Mar 7, 2008 10:16:56 GMT -5
Please don't take offense michaeljohn & others, but do those of you that are arguing against have an engineering background? I do so I understand exactly what you are saying and I agree theres no scientific evidence and thats fine. However, what I don't understand is the tendency of engineers, myself included, to need scientific proof for everything. As I've aged I've become more tolerant of folks that believe in things such as the metaphysical effects that have been discussed. Please try to look at both sides. I've haven't seen any scientific evidence presented pro or con. Just because you don't believe in something theres no need to ask for proof that you already know doesn't exist either way. I'm an engineer and I believe in God, but I don't need proof that he exists.
|
|
|
Post by Michael John on Mar 7, 2008 10:48:06 GMT -5
I just Googled "chrysocolla metaphysical", and here are the sad-but-true results: The first result is www.sobrietystones.com. Here are just the first few things they say about it... A blue green member of the quartz clan. Also known as Gem Silica.
Color: Solid Lt. blue/blue-green.
5th Chakra
Astrological Signs: Gemini and Taurus
Vibrates to the numbers 4 and 7SO ... now rocks have "clans"! Isn't THAT interesting! Chrysocolla is a type of quartz? Hmmm ... good to see they've done their research. This clown has decided to link rock voodoo with astrological voodoo ... isn't THAT special (sayeth The Church Lady). Chrysocolla "vibrates" to numbers??? I wonder if this genius would care to explain the science behind that claim. Are these numbers referring to cycles per second (hertz)? Funny ... all this time I've been mining Chrysocolla, not once has a piece vibrated. The second result is www.metaphysical-store.com. Apparently, these folks MUST be doctors, because here's one of their claims about Chrysocolla: Chrysocolla has been known to aid in preventing ulcers, digestive problems and arthritic conditions. It strengthens the lungs and thyroid gland and also enhances one’s metabolism. It is excellent for female disorders.Folks, this kind of misinformation should be illegal. What if some "new ager" read that and decided to buy some Chrysocolla instead of going to a doctor for real treatment? Psycho mumbo-jumbo claims are one thing, but making these sorts of absolutely unsubstantiated claims regarding physical wellness is just plain wrong. OHHH ... but WAIT ... you can buy a little chunk of "Gem Silica" from them for only $438!!! I get it! Since they have the "cure", they should be paid as much as real doctors! Of course! That makes PERFECT sense! Here's the link to buy the "Gem Silica" miracle cure, for any of you who may wish to continue supporting the "metaphysical properties" of stones: www.metaphysical-store.com/merchant.mv?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=OAMCS&Product_Code=15-CHRYS3But there's MORE: The third result is www.rocknrocks.com. Sure enough, they're "experts", too! Chrysocolla is a solid light-blue or blue-green member of the quartz family. It is also known as Gem Silica.These people are TOTALLY ignorant about Chrysocolla, yet they feel that they're qualified to sell it for it's "metaphysical benefits"? THEY DON'T EVEN HAVE THE SLIGHTEST CLUE ABOUT WHAT CHRYSOCOLLA IS, yet again, they feel that they are qualified to make claims that it can cure serious physical ailments ... It is helpful with the heart, blood sugar, and emotional balance. High it draws out pain, heat (fevers, arthritis, inflammation, etc..), and is an excellent therapeutic aid for healing loss, incest, and other traumas.. Great, so somebody with heart disease and diabetes reads this, buys a chunk of Chrysocolla, and skips their doctor's visit. Yeah, these people DEFINATELY have your best interests in mind ... NOT. This site claims that if you were molested by one of your family members, a chunk of Chrysocolla will fix you right up! These were the FIRST THREE sites that came up in the search. I didn't go looking for sites that would support my point of view. I didn't have to. They're all the same ... deceptive liars, feeding on the weak. It makes me sick ... hmmm but maybe there's a rock that'll cure that! Does anyone still want to continue supporting or promoting the "metaphysical benefits" of rocks, there-by enabling these predators?
|
|
|
Post by cpdad on Mar 8, 2008 23:27:19 GMT -5
i dont care 1 way or the other ;D....fanatic...ya wanna know about engineering...what would you like to know ;D....do you want me to start throwing formulas?...do you want complicated trig problems? ;D...oh ya i can provide all...i spend all of my time with engineers....i work with some of the foremost engineers in the world.
nuclear engineers. electrical engineers, hydraulic engineers, hydrostatic engineers....just to name a few....so dont start getting off because you are an engineer.
i have meet some engineers....that are the smartest...dumbasses i have ever met.
in other words dont give us the ....im an engineer routine....it means not a lot....kev..
|
|
calxoddity
off to a rocking start
Me lying sideways on custard spill
Member since February 2008
Posts: 19
|
Post by calxoddity on Mar 9, 2008 1:26:55 GMT -5
Hi Everybody! Wow, this is too much fun of a thread to just sit on the sidelines and eat popcorn. Excuse me for a second whilst I put on my helmet and running shoes...
What we have here is another religion, which just happens to revolve around rocks. As with anybody's religious beliefs, I'm entirely okay with them holding to that belief system on two strict conditions: don't preach to try to convert me, and don't confuse belief with fact.
I have some very good friends that I give away crystals to, because I know they enjoy them and they believe all of the metaphysical stuff about crystals. I don't and they know I don't, but we're all okay with that.
One thing that really bugs me though is when pseudo-science gets trotted out to support a particular view on why crystals matter. Let's start with with quartz. Because quartz has been found to vibrate under very specific and predictable cirumstances, we now have the claim that quartz vibrates under all circumstances all the time, or the throwaway line "because quartz vibrates..." (my hamsters have brighter eyes or whatever).
So, onto some questions that have perplexed me about crystals: - do natural quartz crystals vibrate more than fake crystals (ie ones that are shaped by hand)? - will heat treated amethyst now posing as citrine behave like citrine or amethyst? - why are metaphysical properties of crystals attached to amorphous minerals, cryptocrystalline minerals, and minerals cut into crystal shapes that don't exist for that mineral? - why can there be no placebo effect associated with crystal healing, yet the placebo effect is a very real effect associated with any healing method or belief, to the extent that it must be planned for and controlled to allow accurate medical testing to be conducted?
Regards, Calx
|
|
snivlem
starting to spend too much on rocks
Member since February 2008
Posts: 167
|
Post by snivlem on Mar 9, 2008 1:51:28 GMT -5
Calx, rocks and crystals are simply forms of matter vibrating at specific rates. Energy aggregates into the building blocks of matter. Within the quarks, atoms, molecules and so forth, energy is omnipresent, in continuous motion, continuous vibration. This energy is actually infinite, existing in every form of matter, anti-matter, space, light, etc., interconnecting each and all. That is pretty much scientific fact, but when looked at in this perspective, it seems "metaphysical", but is actually grounded in the basic understandings of physics and science in general. To think that some of the stones we carve are millions of years old, but they have been vibrating the whole time, sheesh. The realization of this interconnectedness can remove the need for a belief system, it being replaced with understanding. At least that's what I believe, ahem, understand
|
|
rollingstone
starting to spend too much on rocks
Member since July 2009
Posts: 236
|
Post by rollingstone on Mar 9, 2008 5:41:59 GMT -5
MJ is right of course, but what the heck, might as well take advantage of the folks who want to believe in this stuff. I'm going to set up a website selling human poo... which vibrates to the number two ;D. I hope to have a fresh supply each day.
I will also be selling urine, which vibrates to the number one ;D. If you need a big supply of this product, please give advance notice so that I can drink a lot of water to maximize my vibrational transference energy. ;D
|
|
|
Post by Michael John on Mar 9, 2008 12:34:48 GMT -5
After much thought, research, and soul searching, I've decided to cast-aside my worldly, evil ways and seek to fulfill my true destiny. I'm dedicating the rest of my life to helping others, the best way that I possibly can. When I experienced a spiritual awakening last night, I immediately siezed a flashlight and headed-out to the surrounding desert to round-up evil serpents. I'm proud to present to you, my very first bottle of magic elixir! With bottle in hand, I went to town and recruited my first salesman! Until I can produce enough of my product to fulfill the anticipated monumental demand, I'll be offering another product which will undoubtedly help to increase the quality of life for all of my new age bretheren. I feel better already! Don't you???
|
|
indychris
noticing nice landscape pebbles
Member since April 2008
Posts: 81
|
Post by indychris on Apr 21, 2008 19:55:04 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by kap on Apr 21, 2008 21:51:27 GMT -5
WOW I started breathing better and a great calm overtook me just reading about it. Keith
|
|